Is Your Customer Service AI Driving Customers Away?

Businesses are betting big on AI for customer service—but are they losing human connection in the process? A new Five9 study reveals a troubling gap: 81% of companies use AI in contact centers, yet 40% of customers will abandon a business after one bad experience. Leaders are misjudging priorities like self-service accuracy and wait times, risking brand loyalty in an era where CX defines success. Let’s dive in.

🤖 The AI-Customer Disconnect: Where Businesses Are Missing the Mark

• 81% AI adoption in contact centers—but 40% of customers bolt after a single negative interaction.
• 74% of customers still prefer phone calls for high-stakes issues, defying assumptions about digital-first preferences.
• Accuracy matters most: 66% of consumers prioritize getting correct answers over 24/7 availability.
• Perception gaps: Leaders overvalue chatbots and undervalue agent training—88% of companies now invest in agent support tools, but is it enough?

✅ The Fix: Blending Brains with Heart

Five9’s research suggests winning strategies:

• ✅ Hybrid workflows: Use AI for routine tasks (e.g., bill payments) but route complex issues to humans.
• ✅ Agent empowerment: Deploy AI tools that provide real-time customer insights during calls.
• ✅ Accuracy-first design: Oracle and others are enhancing CRM integrations to reduce chatbot hallucinations.

Niki Hall, CMO of Five9, puts it bluntly: "AI is the foundation, but human understanding is the differentiator."

🚧 Roadblocks: Why AI Alone Isn’t the Answer

• ⚠️ Over-automation: 58% of customers feel forced into self-service even when they need human help.
• ⚠️ Trust deficits: Only 12% of consumers fully trust AI to resolve sensitive issues like healthcare or finance.
• ⚠️ Integration chaos: Legacy systems in mid-market firms struggle to sync AI tools with existing CRMs.

🚀 Final Thoughts: Can Businesses Close the Gap?

The path forward requires:

• 📈 Strategic alignment: Map AI use cases to actual customer preferences (e.g., phone support for emergencies).
• 🤝 Trust-building: Clearly disclose when customers are interacting with AI versus humans.
• 🔄 Continuous feedback loops: Use AI analytics to track sentiment, not just resolution times.

As Hall warns: "Rushed AI deployments without empathy will backfire." The question isn’t whether to adopt AI—it’s how to make it feel human. Do you trust AI with your customer service needs?

Let us know on X (Former Twitter)

Sources: Five9. 2025 Business Leaders Customer Experience Report, May 29, 2025. https://www.cmswire.com/customer-experience/research-shows-human-centered-ai-key-to-cx-success/